Rosina Khan
The monumental architecture of the Ancient Greeks and Romans continues to influence and inspire modern culture. If you have never studied the Classics it can be hard to tell the difference. However, there are subtle (and not-so-subtle) differences. Knowing them can enhance your understanding of the ancient world, or at least give you something to talk about at your next dinner party. All About The Angles Greek temples are often constructed up on a mountain or on high ground. The approach to the temple is itself an experience - a winding path can keep the temple out of view. It is only emerging from a front gate or a path that a tourist experiences the structure in its majesty – seeing the long and the short sides simultaneously. Greek temples are often rectangular in form, the entrance isn’t necessarily clear and they are best approached at an angle. The ingress to a Roman temple is quite obvious. Roman priests ascended a distinct staircase into a temple which was built upon a pedestal. The Temple of Isis in Pompeii, Italy is dedicated to an Egyptian goddess but its Roman construction is apparent. The Temple is set on a platform with a precise main entrance and is a little boring to look at from certain angles. Roman temples are best appreciated from the front. The Columns On The Temple Go Around and Around Generally, the columns of a Greek temple are peripteral – constructed around the temple on all sides. The Temple of Hera (II) at Pestum, Italy is located in a former Greek colony called Poseidonia. Although built using local tufa (not marble) this structure is easily identified as Greek due to its use and placement of columns. If columns are the first feature you notice when looking at a structure – Greek is your safe bet. Roman temples often feature columns in the front. The large Corinthian (fanciest type) columns of the Temple of Artemis in Jerash, Jordan are so large they make the visitor lose their natural sense of scale. Jerash was a Hellenistic (Greek) town, which later became Roman territory in 63 BC so it is a good location to compare the two building styles. Sometimes the sheer size of Roman columns is enough to characterize a structure was built with a Roman eye. Remember the Romans conquered vast stretches of land so you will see Roman-built structures outside of Italy. Some Roman emperors (like Hadrian) admired the Hellenistic world so much they copied Greek architecture, making this topic a little more complicated than I have treated it here. From the use and placement of columns to the scale and entrance of these buildings the architects of the ancient world left us with a wide array of structures to enjoy. Disclaimer: This post is intended to aid non-classicsts and non-architects identify ancient buildings. This is by no means a replacement for actual education.
78 Comments
Matthew Marchesani
9/12/2016 05:55:24 am
In your personal opinion, which of the following is the most aesthetically pleasing: Corinthian, Doric, or Ionic columns?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 06:08:37 am
Corinthian - how about you?
Reply
Matthew Marchesani
9/13/2016 06:19:25 am
Me tooo!
Andrew Lewis
9/12/2016 05:55:36 am
Which do you prefer: Greek or Roman architecture?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 06:09:01 am
ALL of it!
Reply
Taylor Kirsch
9/12/2016 06:13:03 am
I had no idea that these Roman and Greek buildings were made of tufa. For the longest time I thought they were made of marble. Was marble ever associated with architecture or just marble sculptures?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 08:31:54 am
Taylor,
Reply
Tova Burton
9/12/2016 06:32:57 am
I did not know that greek structures were often build high up off of the ground. I can't believe that there are still structures today! How do you think they were not destroyed over time?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 08:33:09 am
Tova,
Reply
JT Morris
9/12/2016 07:50:15 am
Would you rather study Roman or Greek architecture, and which one of more common in the United States?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 08:33:52 am
JT,
Reply
Tate Sams
9/12/2016 09:00:54 am
Which would you rather study? Greek or Roman architecture?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 10:29:28 am
Both!
Reply
Stephen Hoke
9/12/2016 09:08:49 am
Which type of column, Corinthian, Doric, or Ionic, is most prevalent in the rest of the world?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 10:30:21 am
Not one particular kind - they are sometimes prevalent in sections of the world, i.e. specific areas.
Reply
Ben Androne
9/12/2016 09:13:26 am
My house is like a roman temple with 2 big columns on the side but none around the other places.
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 10:30:57 am
That's awesome Ben!
Reply
Matthew Marchesani
9/13/2016 06:22:00 am
Nice!
Reply
Stephen Hoke
9/13/2016 09:28:09 am
Neat!!
Reply
Katie Melind
9/12/2016 09:35:58 am
Why were Greek temples constructed on high ground or on a pedestal? To add to the overall experience or to protect from water damage?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 10:32:47 am
It's the Roman temples that were built on pedestals. They simply made the temple higher and grander.
Reply
Jack Moore
9/12/2016 10:29:18 am
Which is more common in the U.S.?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 10:33:43 am
Well . . .no Ancient Greek and Roman architecture here, just buildings inspired by them.
Reply
Tommy Dugan
9/12/2016 10:29:53 am
Were the columns used more for a structural purpose or were they mainly used to please the eye?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/12/2016 10:34:15 am
Both Tommy!
Reply
Naomi
9/12/2016 10:56:33 am
Was Hadrian's style a mix of both Greek and Roman? Or more Roman with Greek embellishments?
Reply
Leigh Anne Roth
9/12/2016 11:51:49 am
It is really interesting how you can identify if the building is Greek or Roman by the columns. If the columns are tufa rather than marble and the placement of the columns then you know it is Greek.
Reply
kayla Fitts
9/12/2016 12:12:38 pm
All the architecture from the Greeks and the Romans are very interesting, but for me I could have to say I like the Greek architecture more. Would you say you like the Roman or Greek better and why?
Reply
Jay higgins
9/12/2016 12:13:30 pm
I Loved the text
Reply
Germans McKay
9/12/2016 12:13:51 pm
Really interesting that Roman and Greek architecture are both kind of similar and take inspiration from one another.
Reply
Mikey O'Sullivan
9/12/2016 12:14:09 pm
I am curios when did Latin officially become a dead weekend
Reply
Ferrus Aurelius Garino
9/12/2016 12:18:08 pm
Planning on using greek-esque architecture for something in minecraft-this will likely help!
Reply
Lane Erickson
9/12/2016 01:37:21 pm
What is your favorite greek or roman piece of architecture? Were these building built on some kind of scale? Who were major architects at this time?
Reply
Amy Loberger
9/12/2016 01:49:52 pm
How do you think it is that many of these Greek and Roman structures are still here today and not completely collapsed and destroyed?
Reply
Joe Kucer
9/12/2016 02:11:56 pm
Do you prefer Greek or Roman architecture?
Reply
Sean Swenson
9/12/2016 02:15:36 pm
Did you take these pictures? Who would you side with in a war?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/13/2016 06:02:21 am
yes I did! I have no idea.
Reply
Kendall Morris
9/12/2016 02:19:52 pm
I noticed that Romans only seem to decorate the fronts of their temples, whereas Greeks usually decorated all the sides. Is there a reason for this?
Reply
Jake Hurst
9/12/2016 02:32:50 pm
For the Temple of Isis that was in Pompeii, why were they worshipping Egyptian gods when it was in the Roman Empire's territory? Wasn't it even against the law to worship other gods other than the Roman ones?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/13/2016 06:11:13 am
The cult of Isis was a cult of social mobility in the republic and soon became a cult of the nobility. It's an interesting cult.
Reply
Drew Baumgart
9/12/2016 02:57:05 pm
I know you prefer the Latin language over Greek language but which in your opinion is more interesting to study overall?
Reply
9/12/2016 03:29:27 pm
Was there a certain reason the Greek temples were constructed on a pedestal or high ground?
Reply
Rachel Moore
9/12/2016 03:31:16 pm
Are most U.S. government buildings based off of Roman styles? Most of our buildings only have columns in the front and one obvious entrance.
Reply
Layth Mattar
9/12/2016 04:04:22 pm
In my personal opinion I prefer the Greek architecture over the Roman. Maybe that is only because of the way you described them.
Reply
Addy De Witt
9/12/2016 04:08:35 pm
Why were the Greek temples usually built on high ground?
Reply
Isabella Bonanno
9/12/2016 04:09:04 pm
Why is there such a vast difference between Roman and Greek architecture? What caused this divide between the styles of building?
Reply
Audrey De Witt
9/12/2016 04:14:33 pm
I never knew that you could tell whether a building is Roman or Greek solely on the how the staircase looked or where the columns are placed. It was a very intriguing article to read.
Reply
Kyle Brun
9/12/2016 04:15:58 pm
Are there many examples of when Romans would use greek influences or architecture within their villages and cities?
Reply
Ethan Krohne
9/12/2016 04:32:57 pm
What is your favorite piece of architecture that you have seen?
Reply
Audrey Meyers
9/12/2016 04:35:14 pm
I never noticed that so much of our architecture today is actually based of the Greek and Roman architecture until seeing the different aspects of the two styles.
Reply
MacAlister Perkins
9/12/2016 04:49:13 pm
Was art ever added on the architecture? If so is there a difference between Greek and Roman
Reply
Myja
9/12/2016 04:55:56 pm
Would you live in a Greek or Roman Temple?
Reply
Michael Gerritzen
9/12/2016 05:15:35 pm
What is your favorite structure in the United States based off of Greek or Roman architecture? Also I prefer Greek architecture over Roman.
Reply
Belle Hinshaw
9/12/2016 05:22:37 pm
Referring to the large Corinthian columns of the Temple of Artemis in Jerash, do you think the Romans intended to make the columns so large that they were/are quite ominous? Whether it was purposeful or not, it was a good move, because I'm sure those depicted the power of the Roman Empire to visitors.
Reply
Jack Cota
9/12/2016 05:58:59 pm
Do you think that any of these temples were used to worship gods or to make sacrifices?
Reply
Erik Klem
9/12/2016 06:09:18 pm
Why do you think the columns are so important to both Greek and Roman architecture?
Reply
Tanner Seaman
9/12/2016 06:13:09 pm
Why did Romans have one main entrance while the Greeks had all directions open?
Reply
Joey Costello
9/12/2016 06:29:09 pm
Are these types of architectures influential in modern day cities and buildings, if so what are some examples?
Reply
Rosina Khan
9/13/2016 06:09:23 am
Yes - next post!!!
Reply
Peter Tuttle
9/12/2016 06:48:41 pm
Do you prefer Greek or Roman architecture and why
Reply
Ben Hannel
9/12/2016 06:54:37 pm
Why were the Greeks temples at the top of mountains and the Romans temples were just atop a pedestal
Reply
Seth Hall
9/12/2016 06:56:37 pm
Was each type of style better for a different type of structure?
Reply
Matt Sebree
9/12/2016 07:05:31 pm
If you were to build a house using either Greek or Roman architecture, which would you use?
Reply
Michael Boehm
9/12/2016 07:08:12 pm
The temple of Artemis's columns remind of the columns of the Smithsonian. Have you ever been to the temple of Artemis?
Reply
Ethan Lowry
9/12/2016 07:16:18 pm
Why do they make the columns so large?
Reply
Molly Kennedy
9/12/2016 07:39:50 pm
What person used columns first in their architecture?
Reply
Romulus Potts
9/12/2016 07:49:56 pm
How many of these buildings have you visited?
Reply
9/13/2016 04:13:30 am
I know that you love both greek and roman architecture but what makes each of them to stand out to you, that you like so much about them both?
Reply
Zach O'Connor
9/13/2016 04:46:06 am
Do you prefer Greek or Roman agriculture? I like Greek more then Roman agriculture, because of the way they built their temples.
Reply
Julia Phillips
9/13/2016 05:06:50 am
Is the architecture for each God or Goddess different based on what the God is known for? Or are they any distinct features to tell which temple belongs to whom?
Reply
Charlie Rohen
9/13/2016 06:53:00 am
If you could go back and visit all the places you took pictures, would you go back?
Reply
Evan Weiss
9/13/2016 06:56:40 am
What's your opinion on the restoration of these monuments?
Reply
Katie Hale
9/13/2016 07:15:06 am
About how many stories are the columns on the temples?
Reply
Garrett Jones
9/13/2016 08:24:35 am
Are there any architectural differences in the building based on what god or goddess it for?
Reply
Adam Vander Kooy
9/13/2016 10:56:47 am
Very interesting information
Reply
Carter Bice
9/14/2016 07:19:12 am
Would the United States Supreme Court Building be more influenced by Greek or Roman architecture?
Reply
Walker Jinks
9/14/2016 08:36:35 am
nice work Magistra
Reply
Jack Roudebush
9/14/2016 10:37:46 am
What was the point of the columns? Were they used as an artistic choice of to hold the temple up?
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorRosina Eileen Khan is an Archives
January 2017
Categories |